doubt about sunset.. .

[PiegatoreSolidworks]

I remember that at your first message you asked what was a good specific program for sheet bending.. you were already using and learning swx:biggrin:

I think you're doing enough with swx, right?
I think that for "normal" bending and rolling goes discreetly well, what do you say after a little use?

greetings
Marco:smile:

hi sampom regarding the use of solidworks I have to say that I am very satisfied especially this 2010 that has the multilamiera that makes me very comfortable....incertainly it affects me very also solidedge but the design method is different from what we use. we say that solidworks perhaps approaches more to inventor in some respects... .

 

[sampom]

:finger:

......

Have you seen the last file?
It's useless to shape the solid, isn't it?

greetings
Marco:smile:

 

[PiegatoreSolidworks]

:finger:


Have you seen the last file?
It's useless to shape the solid, isn't it?

greetings
Marco:smile:

hi sampom saw the last file you posted me and that of marco74... sincerely I don't really like it, even if it works great, because in the area of the edges it's not very nice. . .
I tried to do it in a mixed way and maybe, aesthetically, it's better...now I attach it to you for your exam!

 

[PiegatoreSolidworks]

my preference for both speed of execution (but I am definitely the donkey) that for practicality is that of solid modeling and conversion in sheet of single faces saving the 3 or 4 files in which we want to divide it and then reassemble it all through sheet together. . .
you must be careful to draw a solid that matches inside the hopper and convert into sheet holding the sheet thickness itself outside the solid.. .

What do you think?

 

[sampom]

hi sampom saw the last file you posted me and that of marco74... sincerely I don't really like it, even if it works great, because in the area of the edges it's not very nice. . .
I tried to do it in a mixed way and maybe, aesthetically, it's better...now I attach it to you for your exam!

Yes, if you like it and you feel good, do it. but did you count the number of operations, features, in the tree? You have exactly twice my size, 16 against 8 (I don't count the 2 bevels you tell me I didn't do).

I did it on the fly getting the odds from your fold, but if you want you can better take care of the sketches by placing the vertices to the right measures, then the shape for the cut is adjusted and the edges are better (which then when it is all welded collected and decappata who sees them? ).

ah, and if you want to start from the solid you can avoid a couple of extruded cuts if instead of the cube you immediately extrude an extrusion of a sketch that already has the two opposite faces shaped with the sauces, this I mean:but also those 2 cuts you can do them in one operation with only 1 sketch. .

You see, there are many possibilities.

greetings
Marco:smile:

 

[PiegatoreSolidworks]

Yes, if you like it and you feel good, do it. but did you count the number of operations, features, in the tree? You have exactly twice my size, 16 against 8 (I don't count the 2 bevels you tell me I didn't do).

I did it on the fly getting the odds from your fold, but if you want you can better take care of the sketches by placing the vertices to the right measures, then the shape for the cut is adjusted and the edges are better (which then when it is all welded collected and decappata who sees them? ).

ah, and if you want to start from the solid you can avoid a couple of extruded cuts if instead of the cube you immediately extrude an extrusion of a sketch that already has the two opposite faces shaped with the sauces, this I mean:View attachment 16126but also those 2 cuts you can do them in one operation with only 1 sketch. .

You see, there are many possibilities.

greetings
Marco:smile:

you sampom are right, I do more passages than you, but, by habit, I am fast like that. Sure that to make a sheet I turn around a bit, I have to adapt to the simplicity and speed of the controls of the label "lamiera" for so easy details!

Sure that with this post I lit a beautiful "discussion"! It fascinates me too much this 3d design program, it takes me badly! then the fact that what I design really realize it in the workshop gives me that desire to push me forward with learning.....

(Sometimes I'm also too "romantic" :biggrin: