challenge cam to comparison

[RS4]

Hello fellow programmers

I allow myself to open this discussion to compare the various integrated cam software and not, to see the potentials and shortcomings of 2.5- 3 and 5 axes fun as you have always done in this magnificent forum :biggrin:

greetings

 

[Paolo.M]

now I can walk

 

[RS4]

test 1 2.5 axes aluminum material or other speed and advances you want indicated by you if you want

Have fun


invited all walkers to walk

 

[Paolo.M]

made a little hurry

 

[RS4]

software catia v5

2.5 axis

colors:

red:rapid

yellow: approaching

blue: retraction


allego img

 

[Paolo.M]

I'll send you the file.

 

[Paolo.M]

calculate zig zag finish step to 45th step 0.1
time calculation if you can without containment profiles

 

[Paolo.M]

calculation time with spherical milling d10 mm increment 0.1
and work tolerance 0.01 56 seconds.
thanks to the "gaming" function the tool does not sink into the hole.
I don't have to waste time detecting disputes with relative lifts.
convenient this function if you have to fresare imported mathematicians not perfectly closed, do not kill the pieces

 

[RS4]

calculation time with spherical milling d10 mm increment 0.1
and work tolerance 0.01 processing for isoparametric 2.5 axis = 22 seconds processing

 

[RS4]

calculation time with spherical milling d10 mm increment 0.1
and work tolerance 0.01


processing for harmonic isoparametrics at surface 4a : 1.32sec processing


normal working on surface 4 axes

 

[RS4]

Ribbed height 0.1mm work tolerance 0.01


angle 45°


2.5 axes angle 45° ridge height 0.1 :38 seconds processing

 

[RS4]

con jump islandRibbed height 0.1mm work tolerance 0.01: 4 seconds processing


angle 45°


2.5 axes angle 45° height ridge 0.1 with jump island

 

[RS4]

you expect other evidence of other cam strength guys come forward

 

[Paolo.M]

Hello rs4,
I can know if you have closed the hole with a surface or if even catia has a floating function
Hi.

 

[peloritano]

you also catia has what you define floating function. in caia is called jump island.... .

 

[Paolo.M]

Hello rs4,
This morning I'm a little caught, I'm getting resentful at night,
Okay?
Hi.

 

[peloritano]

that of the pocket seems to me a elementary exercise.... let's try this...... it is necessary to mill only the walls in red continuously starting from the top down (or however as you want) so that on the piece you do not have lines due to the reattack of the tool (i.e. you want a continuous milling

 

[RS4]

Hello rs4,
I can know if you have closed the hole with a surface or if even catia has a floating function
Hi.

Bye-bye

I have not closed the surface understands it automatically with the isoparametric parameterizes in a dense way a tangent surface

to clear with the active island jump creates macros and skips the hole,

I also created a demo with img attached

 

[peloritano]

I'm not clear.... my nik is hairy that is taken from the name of a train since I always liked you.... I had seen the image attached even if I would have activated the direct function so the tool left and entered the surface tangently at the same time avoiding all those gaps that represent a loss of time

 

[Paolo.M]

that of the pocket seems to me a elementary exercise.... let's try this...... it is necessary to mill only the walls in red continuously starting from the top down (or however as you want) so that on the piece you do not have lines due to the reattack of the tool (i.e. you want a continuous milling

so it can go
Hi.