• This forum is the machine-generated translation of www.cad3d.it/forum1 - the Italian design community. Several terms are not translated correctly.

substantial differences between catia and solidworks 2011

  • Thread starter Thread starter arzigogolo
  • Start date Start date

arzigogolo

Guest
Hello, everyone!

My name is lucio and I have been a mechanical designer for several years. I started with autocad, then I went to inventor (which is what I know best because I use for more time) and currently I am learning pro/e and solid edge st3 with good results.

I occasionally use solidworks 2011 and I have to say that potentially, is what I might prefer if it wasn't for some limitations.

I am very passionate about 3d programs for mechanics and I would like to know, synthetically, the main benefits of caia compared to solidworks 2011.

That is, very concretely, what are the real differences that distinguish the two programmes?

Basically, what does one other does not do and how does it do it better?

I would like to know, in particular, the differences between the two programmes regarding the three environments: part, together and put in the table.

As I work mainly in autonomous, for now the functionality that allows to work simultaneously on the same project I do not care much.

more than anything, they are the potential of the two programmes directly compared that would interest me to know.

I apologize for the question that you may have already heard ask who knows how many times, but I would like to hear from those who certainly know better than me the two programs, which of the two would be worth buying.

the scope in which I work is essentially the mechanical one, i.e., assemblies of various mechanical components such as transmission shafts, bearings, gears, etc., and also a lot of light carpentry, then module for iosa sheeting.:biggrin:

thank you all!:smile:
 
I am very passionate about 3d programs for mechanics and I would like to know, synthetically, the main benefits of caia compared to solidworks 2011.


hi argigogolo, catia is very powerful softwear and know how to use it and a value.
solidwork is a toy.
Hello gianluigi
 
Catia is the best sw in the world.
you can do everything and more
you are a great stef ...:biggrin::biggrin::biggrin::biggrin:

cmq is condivided right, but also pro/e is comparable not in all but it is strong stef not to forget it
 
And after the "slogans" I really want to see what you say...
ps. Maybe comparing the prices of the 2 brothers. :biggrin:
 
Excuse me, but what does this discussion have to do with catechism v6?
if I do not erro there is a special section for the comparison of cad's
edit: move!
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Forum statistics

Threads
44,997
Messages
339,767
Members
4
Latest member
ibt

Members online

No members online now.
ciao
Back
Top