special representation n°5

[andream12]

Good evening, I'm an engineering student. can I kindly ask you an opinion on the design I made? I had to extract the particular n°5 (background).
Thank you very much in advance for availability.

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

It's wrong. see the suggestions that have been given to you the other times

 

[andream12]

Thank you very much for the answer. Do I need to review geometry?

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

"You should print the image of the exercise, highlight the contours of the component"

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

Thank you very much for the answer. Do I need to review geometry?

you can see at the eye immediately: you made a straight hole while the image is not

 

[luca234]

I refer the design with the correction hoping it is done well, but I do not think as it seems to me that the valve sticks in component 4. I can't see component 5 well as covered

 

[Fabietto]

Hello, because this request made it in the section
"forum students architecture/engineering"

while the other one made it
"Mechanical engineering students"?

 

[andream12]

I correct myself immediately, I think I have understood better how the component is made, I refer immediately

 

[Fabietto]

I want to help you. .
from above, the inner part of component 5 is formed by:
- threaded part
- fillet drain throat
- seat for valve guide
- valve seat ending with a bevel where it closes the valve head. .

 

[andream12]

Hello, because this request made it in the section
"forum students architecture/engineering"

while the other one made it
"Mechanical engineering students"?

I wonder if I was wrong section, honestly I didn't notice how new I was in the forum, I thought they were both good as students.

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

I wonder if I was wrong section, honestly I didn't notice how new I was in the forum, I thought they were both good as students.

had already been noticed

Estrazione particolare da complessivo

Se provi a disegnarlo in assonometria (vista 3D), uno schizzo a mano senza misure o proporzioni corrette, di come te lo immagini, magari ti può aiutare..

www.cad3d.it

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

I refer the design with the correction hoping it is done well, but I do not think as it seems to me that the valve sticks in component 4. I can't see component 5 well as covered

the design is very understandable, there is nothing hidden. print that damn design and highlight the contours....

 

[luca234]

Thank you very much for your advice. Send the correct section

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

in two you cannot make a decent design.

 

[luca234]

send correct section

 

[luca234]

of course I forgot the restraint

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

I don't like being taken by my ass, so that you are goingream12 or luca 1234 I tell you that such a design should not take more than a 4.

Of course you're two to alternate as if you were one was reported.
I ask other users to weigh the answers until the situation is clear.

 

[luca234]

I am the same person, I have two accounts so this happened, however I send again the section hoping it is right

 

[luca234]

I don't like being taken by my ass, so that you are goingream12 or luca 1234 I tell you that such a design should not take more than a 4.

Of course you're two to alternate as if you were one was reported.
I ask other users to weigh the answers until the situation is clear.

I've already clarified the situation, and I apologize for disappointment.

 

[Tristan]

I wonder if I was wrong section, honestly I didn't notice how new I was in the forum, I thought they were both good as students.

moved to the correct forum. try to make more attention