consigliate thing?

[wonderboban]

hi to everyone. I would have some advice to ask:
I have to draw mechanical parts for products for my company and I would like to have some advice on what is best...some say catia, other pro-e.what are you recommend? what is that with the easiest approach and with valid tutorials to learn?
thanks and good day to all.. .

 

[Mario SJPD]

the right answer is tecnigraph!!!:biggrin:

there are many factors that affect such a choice from economic to technical and management and compatibility... the info you provide are absolutely insufficient for any advice...no advice I can give you seen the cost of the programs and their maintenance if they are only the mechanical parts for the products entrusted to an external professional/technical study surely to your company you agree.

 

[gerod]

bass band quoto.
impossible answer, depends on multiple factors.

 

[wonderboban]

I try to deepen. ..I have to draw product assemblies.
I should try to bring in 3d what I design with cad 2d, so to have a simulation of the finished products before making the samples. I have no great demands, but I would like to approach myself with a professional program so that, if I have to commit some time to learn, I do not find myself in a year to say that it was better to use this rather than that because what I chose does not do some things. the important is the result. . .

 

[cacciatorino]

I try to deepen. ..I have to draw product assemblies.
I should try to bring in 3d what I design with cad 2d, so to have a simulation of the finished products before making the samples. I have no great demands, but I would like to approach myself with a professional program so that, if I have to commit some time to learn, I do not find myself in a year to say that it was better to use this rather than that because what I chose does not do some things. the important is the result. . .

What kind of products? plastic parts design? Mechanical automation? lethronic cards?

If for example you have to do style objects, you will need to cad that treat the supers very well (continuity' g1, g2, those things ') so you will have to go on high-end catia pro/e ug products. if instead you do turned or fried stuff well a medium-range cad (inv, if, swx etc).

with pro/e you have the advantage of scalability, in the sense that you can train with a basic module and then possibly buy new modules if your seigencies should grow. If you take a mid-range you're a little limited in growth, but you save a lot of money and you're usually with a cad easier to use and for which you find more easily collaborators who know it.

 

[wonderboban]

are made of aluminium and plastic with inside electronic parts.
So inventor or similar advice?

 

[cacciatorino]

are made of aluminium and plastic with inside electronic parts.
So inventor or similar advice?

I don't have any experience on those products, maybe you'd better get some demonstrations from sellers your products (the models made specifically for demos are good all).