deeply mute software?

[Trabastia]

Good evening to all,
project plants (modelling piping, hvac and channel portacavi) for yachts over 40mt and fleeting ships for 19 years. from model 3d step to the impaginato 2d, thanks to which the commissioning yard proceeds to the assembly of the pipes.
I have always used microstation and its plantspace.
double monitor, in the first monitor two windows: front and transversal; in the second monitor seen in the plant (fincantieri setting). I attach screenshots of the black/grey water system of a 42 mt, where you can see the working setting, and a screen where you can see the isometric of the plant stress.
I would like to put myself "in my own" and invest on another software (without abandoning completely plantspace), I heard a lot of talk in the cadmatic environment, but I don't know the costs and I have heard discordant opinions, would you advise me and give me your opinion on some sw?

Thank you very much.

Say hi.

 

[falonef]

I don't know the software you mentioned.

I know for saying that in catia v5 of the dassault systemes there is a piping module but I don't know how much it costs and if it happens to you.

 

[Trabastia]

Hello, falonef,
I have info about catia, but it is not suitable for piping, especially in the naval field ,

 

[falonef]

I also saw something in hicad software, they also have an integrated pdm.

 

[meccanicamg]

with solidworks I saw do several things on ping with welding tubes, section changes, various joints etc.
According to me many software have the module that needs to be implemented by building the "base" models to be used to make the various plants.

 

[mawell]

Bye to all,


I am also looking for information about piping that are not easily found online.

from my research it seems that the top program is plant of the autodesk, and then follows esapro. I do not only look at piping but also datasets, p&id, pfd and all this related to a chemical piping, so not simple aeration.

But I come from the solidworks world and have not yet understood whether there is a plant application for solidworks that is at the same level as plant or hexapro. or at least I want to understand if it makes sense to use solidworks.

Thank you very much

 

[cacciatorino]

Good evening to all,
project plants (modelling piping, hvac and channel portacavi) for yachts over 40mt and fleeting ships for 19 years. from model 3d step to the impaginato 2d, thanks to which the commissioning yard proceeds to the assembly of the pipes.
I have always used microstation and its plantspace.
double monitor, in the first monitor two windows: front and transversal; in the second monitor seen in the plant (fincantieri setting). I attach screenshots of the black/grey water system of a 42 mt, where you can see the working setting, and a screen where you can see the isometric of the plant stress.
I would like to put myself "in my own" and invest on another software (without abandoning completely plantspace), I heard a lot of talk in the cadmatic environment, but I don't know the costs and I have heard discordant opinions, would you advise me and give me your opinion on some sw?

Thank you very much.

Say hi.

What is the commercial object of your business? If you have to sell "signs" or any design documents, I think the choice is to match your most important customer. data transfer between different offices is often the needle of the scale that makes choosing a design provider rather than another.

 

[mawell]

true, but we are epc, so we sell, we design, we build. we do medium-sized fumes treatment plants, therefore it serves dedicated specialized program. I have 3 alternatives, but I can't compare them because I don't find anyone who knows them together.

If someone can write something about these sw, I thank:
plant (autocad)
esapro
smap3d (solidplant)

Good day