• This forum is the machine-generated translation of www.cad3d.it/forum1 - the Italian design community. Several terms are not translated correctly.

prices fall in comparison. .

  • Thread starter Thread starter rubo825
  • Start date Start date

rubo825

Guest
Hello, I wanted to know, very approximate, the prices of the basic versions of the most used cads. .
- inventor
- solid edge
-
- solid work
- Catia
 
What for? Are you considering a hypothetical purchase or is it just your curiosity?

greetings
 
solidworks standad --> 6500
solid edge:
2800-3000 euro for base (very limited), 6500 for foundation, comparable to standard swx

add VAT and first year of assistance, not included in the price.for other cads I don't know, I never treated them.

consider however that in negotiations commercials usually have the margin to make big discounts, if things get hurt (for them).
 
prices depend on the moment, the crisis and the quantities.
I think multinationals pay a ridiculous price.
I don't believe it if they show me the invoices.
These companies put in line all the contenders and say: do you want to go out with the joint that says that we are your customers? Well, how much is our name worth?
are always "directional" customers, vars are cut off and do not take a lira.

However in principle, if you are a new customer (small) with about 5000 euros + take a license at home ... in some cases (catea or nx) you will spend more because they have the cousin in the house to do as a cap for the mid-range market, in other cases less (inventor and solid edge that zoppo).
 
prices depend on the moment, the crisis and the quantities.
in fact the price of a software covers practically only the fixed costs, because the variable costs, apart from the price of the CD, the stamp and the management of the practice, are not there.
therefore the price oscillation according to the crisis is much greater than other products with a greater rate of variable cost.
 
to give an idea: the cost of software development and plugins (not negligible) can affect from 10% to 50% of what the customer pays: the rest is due to the cost of marketing and distribution (not to mention the political costs as mentioned maxopus). from here we understand how the margin in case of "big names" (e.g. ferrari) is very high.
 
pro-engineer foundation xe of list costs 6400, to this you can add maintenance non-booking that costs about 1800 euros per year.
Bye.
 
but proe costs less than sw?
Let's talk about the basic version, which should have the same functions.

swx has good that already with the base they give you the mini-fem, it seems to me that in solidedge foundation there is not, I do not know pro/e and inventor.
 
Let's talk about the basic version, which should have the same functions.

swx has good that already with the base they give you the mini-fem, it seems to me that in solidedge foundation there is not, I do not know pro/e and inventor.
in the base of pro/e have also integrated fem lite,cam lite,manikin lite,efx lite.

always 6390 euro a list.
 
but proe costs less than sw?
we are there, between the basic version of pro/e and the office of swx there is practically no price difference.
If I had to choose again I would have no doubt, while being swx a good application, pro/e is another story.
 
Well, in base swx you have all the welding functions, with efx lite you make us assemblings of 30 pieces (for those who make carpentry it does not serve anything), I with swx welds I drew a whole plant.
the office of swx has:

reconnaissance of functions
rendering
standardized library (toolbox)

In my opinion the choice between a midrange and proe should not be based on the price, are two different products and not comparable.
with the only swx base is more complete, but you want to go further with proes you spend more but you can get what onlya big can give you.
It is difficult to explain, but it is good to orientate on a big when needed and you are willing to spend more.
to make another comparison the premium of swx costs little less than 10k€ and costs 2250 €/year of maintenance, to have the same packages in proe it is difficult to stay under double and maintenance would go to 3-4 times.
In essence if you just need the foundation of proe you can consider comparable prices, elevations I wouldn't say.
I repeat the concept: If you need a big you have to go on proes, but if you don't need it, it costs you less a mid.

another tip: If you have particular problems go to make a tour on the sites of the various manufacturers and check if there are the applications you are looking for, for swx there is everything done by third parties, for others I don't know. proe has a lot of "homemade" from the same ptc.
even in this case an eye at prices does not hurt.
 
king ... is not so, even in the pro/e foundation you have the recognition functions, renderings and those that in swx call toolbox (even if management is different ... and in pro/e there are things in the fdu that you humans can not even imagine:biggrin:).
in the foundation pro/e there is a cam lite, a fem lite and other things that can come back useful.

for what concerns welded ... probably efx's lite version is less performing than swx welded but, the full version is once again another planet.
and if you add it to the foundation you get a price net of the discount that is probably below 10'000 euros.
 
Obviously efx lite is limited because it is quarrel, but in order to be able to play and understand the functionality is more than enough, it also does not manage only the soldered.
a list costs 4500 euro mnt 850.

greetings
 
Obviously efx lite is limited because it is quarrel, but in order to be able to play and understand the functionality is more than enough, it also does not manage only the soldered.
a list costs 4500 euro mnt 850.
I'm sorry!
4500+850 uro to "play and understand its features" with a true lite application? :eek:
I think "no bbuono bissiness.. " [cit. Totò] :smile:
 
I'm sorry!
4500+850 uro to "play and understand its features" with a true lite application? :eek:
I think "no bbuono bissiness.. " [cit. Totò] :smile:
Marco, you start losing your shots.
efx lite is included in the foundation (so it costs nothing).
is the full efx that costs 4500 euros...
 
I'm sorry!
4500+850 uro to "play and understand its features" with a true lite application? :eek:
I think "no bbuono bissiness.. " [cit. Totò] :smile:
:-) but please me to stay on the subject of the immense tota.
Marco, you start losing your shots.
efx lite is included in the foundation (so it costs nothing).
is the full efx that costs 4500 euros...
Exactly, I thought I explained well, obviously being squirted someone does not understand me. :wink:
 

Forum statistics

Threads
44,997
Messages
339,767
Members
4
Latest member
ibt

Members online

No members online now.
Back
Top