rank tra solidworks e solid edge

[camale82]

Hello everyone, I'm looking for opinions.
I know that the subject has already been touched, but the discussions are of 2010, a little old, so now I am to ask you the following question, and I address only to those who had like me the burden and the honor to use solidworks and solidedge.
what are the strengths of one and another? I don't want sw because or I would like to know your opinion on the strengths of one and the other.
Tuesday in the company I have a sw vs if to assess whether to stay with one or change on the other, I tell you nothing else not to influence the opinions.
In the meantime, thanks to those who will answer me.

 

[cacciatorino]

If you have to change only for the features that can have one or another, I think it's just not worth it: you would encounter considerable problems to achieve marginal improvements: are produced with similar performance, and also the cost I think is comparable.

If instead you have to change for different reasons, such as integration with a pdm, unrepeatable offer on licenses or even perhaps the request for compatibility with an important client, then it is to be seen but is exulated from the specific discourse of the differences between the two software.

In short, I think I change to switch from if to swx or vice versa I don't think it's worth it, in the face of the difficulties of implementation: think only of the reuse of the historian (do not believe him when they tell you that the two cads manage the files of the other very well, simply it is not true).

 

[camale82]

This is nothing, for the products we make sw in my opinion can help a lot with the configurations, and with reverse engineering, while if it could help in the explosions and in the important rendering for us, for the historian is not a big problem, we collaborate with studies that use nx inventor and catia, 90% of the parts are simply converted steps, but we will want to become autonomous, the forecast of the pdm there is but not immediate, first there is to solve
but what problems would we face with change from one to another? on the question anycad I know very well that the road is still long for all and will never reach us.
I wanted some opinions on the features we need to understand what is best for us, to understand what can help us more.
If I were still pearls, I would choose inventors for the ilogic module for example.

 

[Kakisan]

Hi.
according to me (but I am not an expert of if, I used it only 2 years and did not satisfy me much), sw is definitely superior in the modeling of parts, assemblies and welded. the table if you play it au pair with if (in the sense that sw is slower, but it has many more features).
if it has the synchronous that is very valid, but it depends on what you have to do. Can you give us an idea of the product you will have to develop?

 

[geminiano cassa]

missing the best program for mechanical modeling and body shop,
nx simens premium program like catia and creo ptc.in fact in ferrari we are moving on this.
medium band solid edge medium band. to mean invetor or solidworks that the latter uses the same calculation engine. the advantage of nx and solid edge. and synchronous mode where you can switch from parametric to direct modeling. for a designer and

 

[scalva]

missing the best program for mechanical modeling and body shop,
nx simens premium program like catia and creo ptc.in fact in ferrari we are moving on this.
medium band solid edge medium band. to mean invetor or solidworks that the latter uses the same calculation engine. the advantage of nx and solid edge. and synchronous mode where you can switch from parametric to direct modeling. for a designer and

in the bene capito ho. .

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

missing the best program for mechanical modeling and body shop,

This is bullshit because there is no better program.
for the rest you don't understand anything with that mug of words thrown in bulk.
at the first message a good morning and a presentation are welcome

 

[camale82]

We're going

In the meantime you write siemens, ferrari has the capital and of what you have written you do not understand much, at the point if you work in ferrari I try to apply to the nose.
I agree with mass, the best program does not exist.

 

[PIETRO2002]

missing the best program for mechanical modeling and body shop,
nx simens premium program like catia and creo ptc.in fact in ferrari we are moving on this.
medium band solid edge medium band. to mean invetor or solidworks that the latter uses the same calculation engine. the advantage of nx and solid edge. and synchronous mode where you can switch from parametric to direct modeling. for a designer and

I'm sorry, but I didn't understand. Maybe it was a joke!