Amfa4855
Guest
Hello everyone, I am new to the forum!
I would like to kindly ask you your opinion on how much I write. . .
my company, after leaving for a few years, is returning to the field of the automotive and with this it needs to renew the instrument of the technical office, that is the cad of three-dimensional design.
from 2005 for various projects, until today, it has been used inventor 9... simple and unsophisticated program to parer mio, but I don't think I can manage and import files from another company that will join us in the work!
Recently we have seen presentations of both inventor 2010 and solidworks, and I must say that they are now at the same level, although I must say that inventor is always the most intuitive one in use.
I know also of solid edge, because I used it until last year in another firm, and I know of the advantage of the sicrona modeling, very advantageous also for imported solids.
everything is summed up in two choices to do:
opt for inventor, and thus have the possibility to carry out not only "new" projects but also to update those carried forward until now with inventor 9 (and have, since 2011, a sort of synchronous modeling even better than if)
or
opt for solidworks, and cut so with the past (but still using the inventor 9 licenses in which case changes were made to old projects) but be sure to use a child cat tool and surely able to communicate better with files produced by the automotive environment? (I didn't have any feedback about the presence of a "synthesis" 3d creation environment)
I'm not talking about prices because both houses are equal, so it's not discriminating.
excuse the great amount of text
but I wanted to give a clear idea of the situation in such a way as to have, I hope, also your opinion, especially the opinion of those who work like me in prototyping and can always have an extra idea to propose.
Good evening:
flax
I would like to kindly ask you your opinion on how much I write. . .
my company, after leaving for a few years, is returning to the field of the automotive and with this it needs to renew the instrument of the technical office, that is the cad of three-dimensional design.
from 2005 for various projects, until today, it has been used inventor 9... simple and unsophisticated program to parer mio, but I don't think I can manage and import files from another company that will join us in the work!
Recently we have seen presentations of both inventor 2010 and solidworks, and I must say that they are now at the same level, although I must say that inventor is always the most intuitive one in use.
I know also of solid edge, because I used it until last year in another firm, and I know of the advantage of the sicrona modeling, very advantageous also for imported solids.
everything is summed up in two choices to do:
opt for inventor, and thus have the possibility to carry out not only "new" projects but also to update those carried forward until now with inventor 9 (and have, since 2011, a sort of synchronous modeling even better than if)
or
opt for solidworks, and cut so with the past (but still using the inventor 9 licenses in which case changes were made to old projects) but be sure to use a child cat tool and surely able to communicate better with files produced by the automotive environment? (I didn't have any feedback about the presence of a "synthesis" 3d creation environment)
I'm not talking about prices because both houses are equal, so it's not discriminating.
excuse the great amount of text
but I wanted to give a clear idea of the situation in such a way as to have, I hope, also your opinion, especially the opinion of those who work like me in prototyping and can always have an extra idea to propose.Good evening:
flax
