irregular cruise vault with autocad

[Cloe85]

good the first, also to facilitate in the future any research of discussions.

I managed to solve (I don't know how...) the problem of the barrel vault, so no new discussion. instead I have a problem with the quarrel for the creation of another time to cruise. Since the argument is the usual of the initial discussion I think it is better than to continue here, but since it is not practice to direct you as you think better!

the problem is that in this case the lisp does not create me time to cruise, unlike what it did with others.
I believe that it is also good in this case to proceed as I have done before, i.e. to create the intradox and extradox surfaces (by setting the surface option without tracking at the base) and then create the solid with the scolpiscisuperficie option, but I can't make it turn.
the height of the arc is 270 cm, is it possible that it depends on that, since there is not one of the conditions indicated by gp (height of the arc less than half of the longer side of the room)?

attach files with polylinea of the environment.

ps: crystal and figure that the profession makes even the "nientologist"....

View attachment POLILINEA VOLTA A CROCIERA.dwg

 

[GP.]

If the height of the arc is greater than half the side, it must be represented by an ellipse arc.
see how this version of the lisp goes that checks, according to the height, whether to draw arches or elliptical arches.
I don't have time to check why it works with a2014, while a2015 gets angry.

 

[Cloe85]

Then.
the lisp worked for the creation of the intradox surface (arch height 270 cm);
when I go instead to perform the steps for the creation of the esterradox does not work. I tried with an arch height of 305 so that everything will return me a thickness of 30 cm; I saw that autocad says, among other things, that the loft surface intersects itself.

I also tried to generate a solid (always with arc height 270 cm) but I do not get any results.

:frown:

 

[Cloe85]

guys I'm trying alternative techniques but I don't get results.
Does anyone have a light?
the surface (corresponding to the intradox) that the second liso of gp. generates has something strange on one of the ends of the base polylinea. I believe it depends on the fact that one of the perimeter arches "shorts" outside the polylinea and therefore when I go to pull the surface at one point is cut higher than the other three. (the angle in question is the upper right)beyond this fact that I can overlook by pretending that the time on one side you lay higher in the wall, I just can't create the upper surface.
It thickens it works but it creates problems because in the surface to the extremity the nails do not join on the diagonals of the base polylinea and the presence of small "scalini" makes to plan the seismic analysis program.
offset surface does not work on one of the 4 surfaces that make up the vault; If I try to combine autocad after a while, he won't answer.

do you have ideas to create the surface at the end with alternative methods? I also tried as suggested by gp. on page 1, but nothing to do.. .

I attach files if you need it!View attachment POLILINEA VOLTA A CROCIERA4.dwgView attachment 39365

 

[GP.]

It seems to me that the lisp works well with your polylinea, if you want to attach someone as soon as I can try to build something, crossing my fingers...

 

[Cloe85]

:confused
I tried again starting from scratch to make you a file with surfaces that didn't generate me and it worked......... .

Thank you!!! ! ! ! ! !